You’ve seen the inside of my voice-over booth. Now it’s time to talk about technology.
Don’t worry, I’ll do my very best not to be too technical, if only for my own sake.
When it comes to the tools of the trade, I subscribe to the “less is more” philosophy. Life is complicated as is, and in my studio I’d like to keep things as simple as possible.
Without exception, my clients ask for audio that’s “unfooled around with”. Most of them are much better equipped to do post-production sweetening in their studios, if that’s what they want.
I have no inclination to compete with all the high-end bells and whistles their engineers have at their disposal. As long as I can give them clean and clear audio, they’re happy and I’m happy.
Computing Power: the hardware
At the heart of my studio is a Mac Mini with a dual-core 2.3 GHz Intel i5 processor running OS X Lion. It came with 2GB of memory, but thanks to a removable bottom, it is very easy to add more memory to your mini. If you let Apple do it for you, 8 GB will cost you $400. It took me ten minutes to do it myself for less than $45. At the time I even got a $10 rebate and free shipping!
Sorry, but I’m not going to get into the Apple versus PC discussion. I’ve used both and I have found Apple to be more reliable and user-friendly. I do want to tell you what prompted me to get a Mac Mini.
Reason number one: it barely makes any noise. When it does, it produces a whisper that’s almost inaudible.
Some colleagues have a studio with two separate areas: a sound booth and a control room. The computer is usually outside the booth. I combined both spaces, which means that my desktop sits next to me in my studio. The Mac Mini uses very little energy and it rarely ever gets warm. That makes it amazingly quiet.
Secondly, this computer stays in my studio. It doesn’t have to go on the road with me. Otherwise I would have bought the Macbook Air (no moving parts and also nearly silent).
Third: I already had peripherals such as a flat-screen monitor and an ergonomic mouse. I just added a wireless keyboard. Tip: if you want to connect a standard analog computer monitor or LCD to your Mac Mini, you need a Mini DisplayPort to VGA Adapter.
What the Mac Mini doesn’t have is an optical drive to play and burn CD’s or DVD’s. For that purpose I bought the Macbook Air SuperDrive which can be plugged into one of the four Mac Mini USB 2.0 ports.
The actual move from PC to Mac was very easy. It took me about a week to get used to my new computer and the operating system. It’s all rather intuitive. A few weeks ago we did add a MacBook Air to our household. This is no ordinary laptop. It is a work of art!
Backup, please!
We’ve all heard horror stories of friends who lost months if not years worth of irreplaceable data when their system decided to take a permanent break. Backing up is something all of us should do, but we often don’t. We forget. We tell ourselves that we’ll do it tomorrow or the day after. It’s just one more thing to think about, and that’s why I wanted a backup system that would do the thinking for me.
I now have an Apple Time Capsule with a 2 TB hard drive, designed to work with my operating system (although it works with PC’s too). After an initial backup which lasted several hours, it now backs up both computers in our home quickly, wirelessly and automatically. Installing it was a piece of cake. The Time Machine feature in the OS detected the Time Capsule and within minutes it was up and running.
Tip: as the Time Capsule is backing up, it may interfere with your recording. In my case, I noticed a soft but annoying buzzing sound on the audio file, which disappears when the automatic back-up is switched off.
Look at me!
Next on my list was a webcam which I use for coaching sessions, webinars and Skype. I picked the Logitech HD Pro Webcam C910. The Carl Zeiss optics lens has a wide angle and the video quality is remarkably crisp and clear.
Reviewers also praise the quality of the stereo microphones. That’s not so important to me because my sound comes directly from my studio condenser.
Mac users: don’t get all gaga over all the advanced features listed on the box and in the manual (zoom, face tracking, exposure adjustments). Even though Apple sells this camera in their stores, most of the Logitech functionally works on a PC and not on a Mac. The C910 is also not supported as an iMovie camera, but that’s Apple’s fault.
In summary, this camera gets an A for image quality, but a C- for limited Apple functionality.
Software
There are many different types of DAW’s (Digital Audio Workstations) available for audio production on a Mac. Colleagues with a background in audio engineering like to use Pro Tools. A lot of my voice-overs friends rave about Adobe Audition CS5.5 and Twisted Wave. Until I made the switch, I was a happy Sound Forge™ Pro user.
I won’t be going over the pros and cons of each program. You can try most of them out for free and I’d certainly take advantage of that.
I ended up choosing Twisted Wave because it’s very stable, easy to use and at $79.90 it’s also budget-friendly. Thanks to a great interface, zooming in and out of a waveform is very fast, even when the file is quite long. I particularly like the fact that I can zoom in at great detail for precision editing.
Different clients prefer different audio formats and TW can import, export and convert most of them. It has a time-saving batch processing feature which is especially useful when you’re working on a lengthy e-Learning project with lots of short files that need to be separated out and individually named.
TW doesn’t come with a whole lot of special effects, but new and existing plugins are imported seamlessly. With TW, effects no longer have to be applied one by one, but it’s possible to load any number in an effect stack and still adjust them separately.
Some of you might prefer Adobe Audition CS5.5 because it’s loaded with features such as Noise Reduction, a DeClicker, a DeHummer etcetera. I had already invested in Izotope’s RX2 audio repair toolkit and it’s now an integral part of my Twisted Wave Effects line-up.
I do have two items on my Twisted Wave wish list. I’d love to have a feature similar to Adobe Audition’s Auto Heal function for brushing away audio glitches. It’s like having Photoshop® for your audio! I also like to have my Sound Forge WaveHammer tool back. It applies a tad of compression and normalization to the sound files to give the audio just a bit more oomph.
Controlling the Wave
To streamline my job in the editing room I’m using a ShuttlePROv2 controller. It has 15 programmable buttons, a jog knob and a spring loaded wheel with which I can control the main editing functions in Twisted Wave.
It’s preprogrammed for things like Garageband, iPhoto and iTunes, but it was really easy to program the TW keyboard shortcuts into the Shuttle. With my mouse in one hand and my ShuttlePRO in the other, I can scroll, zoom, cut, copy and paste much faster than with a keyboard.
The ShuttlePROv2 connects to your computer via a USB port and it comes with custom labels for the top 9 buttons. It can be used on either MAC or PC computers.
If you’re a regular reader of this blog, you know that I consider myself to be a very lucky man. In December 2011, I won a Microtech Gefell M 930 Ts large diaphragm condenser microphone in a recordinghacks.com giveaway. This microphone happens to be ideal for voice-over work. To find out why, you should read my review by clicking here.
Because the Gefell did not come with a shock mount, I had to find a suspension system that would hold this small microphone. Rycote, a company based in the UK, makes the InVision™ Studio Kit you see in the picture. It’s a combination of a unique, universal shock mount and a very light and effective pop filter. If you click here, you’ll find out what I think of this kit.
I’m using an Ultimate Support® mic stand and their telescoping Ulti-Boom. WindTech cable clips keep the mic cable separate from the stand.
Preamplifier
A good preamplifier strengthens the low level signal coming from your microphone to a level suitable for recording, without degrading the signal to noise ratio (S/N). A preamp with a high S/N has very little background noise.
Some boutique preamplifiers can really color your sound and that wasn’t something I was particularly interested in. My ideal preamp needed to be dead quiet, transparent, detailed and clear in all frequencies.
As I researched preamps within my budget range, I kept coming back to one model: the Grace Design m101.
Built in Colorado, the sound quality is often described as “natural” and “pristine”. I couldn’t agree more. This is a phenomenal preamplifier!
Looking at the front panel, you’ll see a 48V phantom power button, a ‘ribbon button’ which, when engaged, bypasses the phantom power circuit, and a high-pass filter button to reduce low-end rumble and curb the proximity effect of a microphone.
In my review for pro audio dealer Sweetwater, I called this preamp an “Amazing Grace” because it makes my microphone shine.
Audio Interface
In a nutshell, an audio interface connects your microphone and other sound sources to your computer. For audio to be usable by a computer it needs to be digital, and an interface converts your analog signal to bits and bytes. You’ll often find external audio interfaces that include a mic preamp, but since I already had a pre, I opted for the pocket-sized Echo AudioFire2 (discontinued, but still available for around $200).
This device is connected to and powered by the computer via a FireWire bus. I purposely didn’t want to get a USB-interface. The Mac Mini only has four USB slots that fill up pretty quickly and USB devices cannot draw power from the computer. With the AudioFire 2 you can record 24-bit 96 kHz audio with near-zero latency (delay) monitoring.
Because the AudioFire2 has a 400 Mbps FireWire port and the Mac Mini has an 800 Mbps port, you need an adaptor to be able to connect it to the computer. The AudioFire could also use a simple step-by-step set-up guide. Perhaps it’s my lack of technical insight, but it took me a while to make the right connections (literally and figuratively).
Overall, this sturdy, small metal box performs just fine. It’s more of a necessity than anything else.
Monitoring
Like so many of you, I evaluate my audio in two ways: I use headphones and studio monitors. Gear-guru’s often recommend buying closed headphones to prevent sound leaks from feeding back through the microphone. That’s why I got the Sennheiser HD 280 Pro.
These headphones stay put alright, and they shut outside sounds out (not that ambient noise is a problem in an isolated studio). Over time I found them to be quite uncomfortable. I happen to have a rather large head (thanks Dad!), and I didn’t like the tight grip the Sennheiser had on my ears.
The AKG K 240 semi-open Studio headphones I am using now, are very comfy and they provide plenty of acoustic isolation. My ears can breathe! After a year and a half, the cups started showing some wear and tear, and I will replace them soon with velvet ear pads.
The AKG has a regular, straight cable which I also prefer. Somehow, things always get caught in a coiled cable, such as the one that comes with the Sennheiser.
Both headphones are excellent for detailed monitoring.
When it came to picking out a pair of speakers a few years ago, my budget was limited and so was my space. At that time I was recording in a cold corner of the attic, and I got a pair of Alesis M1Active 320USB monitors.
At first I was quite skeptical and I didn’t really expect much from these bookshelf speakers. Once I plugged them in, I was blown away by the fact that so much sound could come out of such a small package. That has not changed.
I’m sure they are no match for a pair of Genelec studio monitors, but for under 100 bucks these Alesis speakers continue to impress me. As you can see, I have placed them on stands at ear hight. It really makes a difference.
Enough already
Alright… I think I’m done shopping for a while, don’t you?
Selecting audio equipment can be a daunting task and it can be a learning experience. Just as a musician has to know his instruments, a voice-over pro has to have a basic knowledge of the tools he or she is using. There’s so much good stuff available these days, and it’s easy to get overwhelmed.
Whatever you do, don’t be intimidated by gear-snobs and audiophiles. Talk to people you trust and whenever possible, try things out for yourself.
Don’t blindly buy something just because some guy at your local Guitar Center told you he loves it, or because Paul Strikwerda wrote about it in his blog.
After all, that’s just a bunch of Double Dutch!
Paul Strikwerda ©2012
Dan Lenard says
Lots of “on the Gelder” advice there Paul!
My thought is never go into a retail operation, physical or online, not knowing what you want. Do your homework. VO in a home studio is a a highly specific area, and to my personal knowledge, an area the retail guys are clueless about. Recording music is very different from recording dry voice.
Your studio is clearly the most elegantly decorated home studio I’ve seen and that clearly creates a personal space that makes you feel at home in your home. It also makes me realize what slob I am.
:-3)
I couldn’t agree more, Dan. That’s why I listed you as one of my go-to sources in my last post. Just as you don’t go to a generic superstore to buy a high-quality mountain bike, serious voice-overs should consider consulting professionals that know this business inside-out.
It’s not always easy to keep my small space free of clutter, but a clean desk (with doggie bed) and a clear mind seem to go together.
Paul…thanks for the share man. I like your frugal approach. Excellent. Still in radio the fight I fight most is outside sound sources and a studio which is far from soncially perfect. Far too much reflection, which I have to get around with mic positioning and post production. But what you’re showing, I think I might shave back on some of my front end processing for in-house stuff I do. I’m running thru a older focusrite pre amp which is pre and a channel strip which includes downward expansion, compression, voice/eq, de-esser. Truth is I’ve never been blown away by it but. But after shelling out the cash…hard to justify dumping it. Again thanks for the share…
You’re very welcome, Dave. My strategy is to get the cleanest possible signal in from the start. That’s also easiest to duplicate in case the clients wants retakes. I’m all for reflection, but more in a philosophical sense, if you know what I mean. In my studio I’d like to tame the echoes as much as I can.
If you have a less than ideal place to record, you might want to look at using a mic with a very tight cardioid pattern (shotgun maybe?), or switch to a dynamic mic like a Shure SM7 or EV RE20. I used these all the time in situations where I don’t want room tone. Of course, depending on your voice you may fight proximity and EQ in post (the sm7 has a bit more midrange honk on certain voices). I have had good results with the SM7 and a Grace Pre for most voices – lots of clean gain which allows the talent to be back from the mic about 6-8 inches -cuts proximity effect.
Thanks for that, Dave. That’s what I just recommend to one of my VO-colleagues in India. He lives in a very busy and noisy neighborhood and has a hard time finding peace and quiet to record.
Gefell has done an excellent job curbing the proximity effect on my M 30 Ts. However, I love having a bit of a bass boost for certain reads. As far as preamps go, the Grace is as pristine as it gets. I love that beautiful black box!
Paul,
something every VO artist should also keep in mind when auditioning preamps and mics – they go hand in hand, and they sound different with each voice. Just because the Gefell mic and pre shines for your voice, doesn’t mean it would work with mine.
For example a Shure Sm7 with a transformer based preamp might be better for some female voices, in order to thicken it up, plus cut out a lot of “room” sound. But it might not be good for a lower male voice – too wooly, and too much proximity effect.
If possible, always audition different mics, and mic preamps. I recommend going to a studio with a decent assortment of mics and pres; pay for a couple of hours of recording, noting the mic and pre combo, and decide what’s best for YOUR voice.
I couldn’t agree more. There are so many variables in the recording chain. Change one of them and everything changes. The set-up in a studio or even at a place like B & H’s mic room is still different from your home studio.
For health reasons, it has become harder to audition microphones at home and send them back. To my knowledge, the Harlan Hogan MXL VO: 1-A is the only mic that can be auditioned and sent back, no questions asked.
Paul would you be open to exporting your Twisted Wave settings for the ShuttlePro?
I have been using the original ShuttlePro for several years, (originally for video editing) and it’s great, but I have had some issues getting the right settings for Twisted Wave.
By the way, after several years of use, and a couple of moves, I lost some of the clear button covers, Contour support was great and shipped replacements right out to me.
Thanks!
DB
Let me find our how I can make that happen, Dan. I have customized the buttons according to my own preference. For that, I had to change some of the TW shortcuts.
The trouble with TW is that the number of shortcuts is limited, so not all functions are covered. I’m still trying to find a way around that.
Exactly what I found Paul. All functions are not covered by a shortcut. I was thrilled when I found that the up and down arrow keys would zoom in and out on the timeline; handy when on the road with a laptop and no ShuttlePro. Thanks for your reply.
DB
Perhaps we can persuade the powers that be at Twisted Wave to give us a few more keyboard shortcuts. For starters, I’d like to see one for “play” and “pause”. That’s not too much to ask, is it?
Paul all you do is go to Edit- Edit Keyboard shortcuts, click on audio – play- and hit “p” or whatever key you want to use to play. hitting P then will both stop and start it.
Thank you, Home Studio Master! You are a shortcut to solving home studio problems. Can I program you into my keyboard?
Paul,
Spacebar – plays
Spacebar – pauses
If that is what you are looking for.
DB
Isn’t a spacebar something astronauts eat?
I think the Spacebar is where “Han Shot First”
Great post. Long time listener, first time caller, as they say..!
Just a note for Pro Tools junkies like me – the ShuttlePro may not be as intuitive with Pro Tools as with other programs. I bought one to go with Pro Tools 9 on a PC and ended up selling it, as the wheel can’t perform the jog/shuttle functions I had thought it would. The ShuttlePro is a USB device, and I think the jog/shuttle commands need to be sent via MIDI. Again, this is only relating to Pro Tools, and I know of people running Pro Tools HD who are happy with the device.
I can vouch for the Rode NT1-A being a lovely mic for male VO. I’ve had one for years. I run it through an MBOX. BTW I’m an Aussie, but have no affiliation with Rode.
Thanks for your comments and for being a “long time listener,” Andy! I don’t know if other pro-toolers have had similar problems with the shuttle. The people at Contour have set up a support community for users that is very helpful. Did they acknowledge the problem?
I have found the shuttle to be a time-saver that has already paid for itself. The nice thing is that it works with many other programs and web browsers too.
The Rode NT1-A is indeed a solid microphone that has earned a very good reputation.
I did have a look at the forums, and I think that’s where I realised the jog/shuttle commands in Pro Tools are MIDI. The preset buttons were handy in Pro Tools and other programs, but I just didn’t find myself using it enough – my old keyboard shortcut habits were refusing to die.
Hi Paul,
This is great advice in terms of equipement. Have a quick question: do you think an iMac is as quiet as a mac mini – my computer is in front of the mic, so sound is a huge issue for me 🙂
Thanks
Noel
Both computers are not completely silent. If you plan on reading your copy off the computer screen, the iMac is closest to your mic and you’re more likely to pick up its noise.
As you can see, my Mac Mini sits next to me in a small cabinet and I can even close the door. Because you can place it further from the mic, it is the best and quietest choice.
I used to read straight from the computer screen, but I found sitting down all day was not great for my back (and I don’t have one of those clever chairs like Paul!)
So I set up a microphone beside my desk with the computer humming quietly under the other side of the desk.
I didn’t want to have to print scripts all the time, so I now send scripts to my Kindle and read from that.
Thanks Paul,
That makes sense and helps me make my decision!
Much appreciated
N
Hi Noel, I’m glad I could be of help to you. Thanks for taking the time to read my blog!